Header

Food Crops: Mutations and Manipulation

Tomatoes
© Jupiterimages Corporation.
You eat mutants! Everybody does, every day. Genomes are constantly undergoing variations in DNA code—mutating—with each generation. Every item in the grocery store has been touched by genetic changes, ranging from the minor to the profound. Today's mammoth tomatoes, for example, can weigh as much as 1,000 times the weight of their wild ancestors. Everything about our food, from size to texture, color, taste, and nutritional content—plus much, much more—is influenced by plant genes.

For many centuries, humans have deliberately cultivated plants with desirable mutations through selective breeding— choosing plants with the best traits and breeding them together. Kiwi fruits, originally hard, unpalatable (but edible) berries from China, were dramatically altered through selective breeding in New Zealand to become the fruit we know today. Scientists can now delve into plants' genomes to find the genes behind particular traits—a much more targeted approach than selective breeding. Identifying key genes enables them to influence changes in plant characteristics more rapidly than ever before.

Genetic mutations—in plants, animals, or any living thing—can be good, bad, or irrelevant for the fitness of the organism Celery
© Jupiterimages Corporation.
itself, or for its human uses. Sometimes, mutations that are beneficial in one way can be debilitating in another. For example, celery naturally produces psoralens, which are irritant chemicals that deter insects from feeding on the plant. Celery plants with elevated levels of psoralens suffer less damage from disease and insects and appeal more to consumers, and therefore, were selectively bred in the 1980s. Unfortunately, workers harvesting or packaging high psoralen-producing celery developed severe skin rashes as a result, and the celery strain was subsequently removed from the market.


Corn: Improving a Critical Staple Crop

You'd be sorely disappointed to find an ear of corn's predomestication ancestor, known as teosinte, on your plate. The edible portions of that plant consisted of just 5 to 12 tiny kernels, each encased in a rock-hard shell. Thousands of years of selective breeding have produced a vastly more productive corn—offering 500 or more delectable kernels on each cob—that has become a staple food in many cultures.

Corn and Teosinte
Image courtesy Nicolle Rager Fuller, National Science Foundation.
Interbreeding modern corn with its ancestor teosinte has shed some light on the genetic changes behind corn's domestication, and even offered clues on when (6,000-10,000 years ago) and where (in southern Mexico) domestication occurred. Scientists have already identified several genes that are responsible for the main changes that differentiate corn from teosinte; these genes have a huge effect on plant growth, as well as on fruit and seed formation. This research has advanced understanding not just of corn, but of how new physical characteristics evolve in other plant species.

Armed with advanced molecular research tools, scientists and farmers are working to improve corn even more. For example, researchers recently identified the genes responsible for corn's vitamin A content. Inexpensive molecular markers, used to identify which plants are expressing a particular gene, are being used to help farmers selectively breed for strains that produce increased amounts of vitamin A. In developing countries, vitamin A deficiency causes eye disease in millions of children each year, as well as many other health effects. Producing corn with a higher concentration of this critical nutrient will be a major boon to public health, particularly in cultures with a corn-based diet.


Cultivated Mutants: Romanesco Cauliflower

Romanesco Cauliflower
Image courtesy of Jon Sullivan.
Romanesco cauliflower attracts attention for its branching, spiraling pattern of growth. Scientists have traced the origin of Romanesco and related cauliflowers to selective breeding by 15th-century Italian farmers. The vegetable's striking shape highlights the incredible amount of variation that can occur within a single plant species; studying such natural variation can provide clues as to how traits develop in plants.

A head of cauliflower or broccoli is actually a collection of immature flower buds. Studying Romanesco and its relatives has provided clues to how flowers are formed. Researchers identified a gene that allowed them to induce Arabidopsis, a weed not closely related to cauliflower, to produce cauliflower-like structures instead of flowers. They dubbed the gene responsible "CAULIFLOWER."


Manipulation of Plant Genes

Many people are aware of the debates about the safety and long-term effects of genetically modifying food crops. Most are not aware, however, of the broad range of approaches genetic modification can include.

Altering a plant's genes does not necessarily mean transplanting genes from another species into the plant's genome. Often, it can mean using the variability of the DNA sequences in a plant's own genes (generated by the mix of DNA from each of its parents) to trigger or suppress certain processes.

Rice
© Jupiterimages Corporation.
For example, scientists are searching for ways to change the time when rice plants flower. If they are able to trigger flowering earlier, it could allow farmers to harvest more crops within a single year in some areas. Other scientists are investigating genes that can make rice plants produce as much as twice the number of rice grains per plant.

In other cases, scientists suppress certain genes to improve a crop's performance. For example, leafy greens such as spinach and lettuce are more productive if flowering is suppressed. This increase is because flowering diverts energy from leaf production to flower and seed production, slowing the growth of the harvested parts of the plant.

Another type of manipulation includes turning a plant's genes on or off to change its height or shape, which can make crops sturdier and more resistant to wind and weather damage.


Genetic Resources

Wild plants that humans don't eat can still be used as a genetic resource. A dozen varieties of apples or four types of potato at the supermarket may seem like a large selection, but these represent a miniscule fraction of the thousands of varieties of apple and potato that exist currently or have existed historically somewhere on Earth. Studying the DNA sequence variation in the genomes of the relatives and ancestors of today's crops can yield insights into basic plant processes and improve crop strains and farming methods.

Tomato
© Jupiterimages Corporation.
For example, humans have cultivated an enormous variety of tomatoes through selective breeding, and, more recently, genetic manipulation. These efforts have been targeted toward producing a more marketable and easily transported fruit. However, some of these beneficial changes to the tomato's size, shape, color, sensitivity to bruising, and rate of spoilage have been gained at the expense of flavor, fueling an increased interest in heirloom and other tomatoes known for their superior taste. Genome sciences provide valuable tools for scientists in search of the optimal good-tasting, but robust, tomato.

Another reason the wild ancestors of crops are of value is their potential for holding the cure to future plant diseases or pests. When a new plant foe emerges, the more places scientists have to look for genes that can boost crop defenses, the higher their chances of finding the right cure for the disease.


The Plant-Pathogen Arms Race

Wheat Stem Rust
Image courtesy Yue Jin, USDA.
Between 1950 and 1954, a rust-colored fungus known as wheat stem rust wiped out as much as 20 percent of the wheat crop across a large swath of midwestern states.

Following the outbreak, scientists created a stem rust-resistant wheat strain that quickly became a favored breed worldwide. But in 1999, a new strain of the fungus was discovered on what had been rust-resistant strains in Uganda. The new stem rust, named Ug99, has many people worrying about the possibility of a global wheat catastrophe.

Wheat provides a substantial proportion of food calories around the globe. It also serves as a feedstock for cows and other livestock. Given the current climate of increasing food prices, combined with the fragile structure of food systems in developing countries, now would be a particularly bad time for a new strain of stem rust to strike. Since its discovery, Ug99 has spread from Africa to the Middle East and appears to be on a track headed toward Asia and North America.

Scientists are racing to develop Ug99-resistant wheat strains. But breeding or engineering a stem rust-resistant wheat strain is a tiny—and moving—target. Wheat and stem rust have coevolved in an epic arms race in which a change in a single gene in the wheat or the fungus can make a plant resistant or susceptible to disease. Genomics research, on both wheat and the wheat rust fungus, are crucial to fighting Ug99 in this high-stakes race against time.


The iPlant: Tools for the Future of Plant Genomics

Genomics research generates enormous amounts of data. One goal is to integrate all of these data to create the "iPlant." The iPlant is conceived as a large family of mathematical models that generate computable "plants" that would provide insight on how plants grow and develop as a system and could be used Achievements of the National
Plant Genome Initiative and New
Horizons in Plant Biologyto predict plant behavior under a range of environmental conditions. Such a tool would allow researchers to do "virtual" experiments to identify the most promising avenues of research before doing experiments in the field. The National Research Council report Achievements of the National Plant Genome Initiative and New Horizons in Plant Biology recommends the development of computational tools that are sustainable, adaptable, interoperable, accessible, and evolvable to achieve the goal of the iPlant.


This web page is based on the National Academies' educational booklet New Horizons in Plant Sciences.

Back Next

Copyright © 2009. National Academy of Sciences
All rights reserved. 500 Fifth St. N.W., Washington, D.C. 20001
Terms of Use & Privacy Statement